The Vatican announced Thursday that priests and members of a breakaway Catholic group that ordained four new bishops in defiance of Pope Leo XIV’s wishes are in schism and excommunicated.
The Society of Saint Pius X, an ultra-traditionalist group, went ahead with the ordinations on Wednesday without papal approval and despite appeals from Leo to reverse the decision. One of the bishops newly ordained is Father Michael Goldade, who leads the group’s seminary in Dillwyn, Virginia.
In response, the Vatican’s doctrinal office on Thursday published a decree saying that the four bishops are excommunicated, along with the two bishops who participated in the ordination ceremony. Excommunication means they are excluded from the sacraments of the church.
It added in an explanatory note that priests belonging to the society and lay members who “formally adhere” to the group are also in schism and excommunicated. The decree warns all “clerics and the lay faithful” not to formally follow the society as they will automatically incur the penalty of excommunication.
The Warning
In a final appeal to the group Monday, Leo had warned that the ordinations would be a “schismatic” act and a “sin of extreme gravity.” The ruling by the Vatican is wide-ranging in clamping down on the group.
Cardinal Pietro Parolin, the Vatican’s secretary of state, expressed his “deep sorrow” on Wednesday about the ordinations, saying they “break the unity of the Church and incur very specific sanctions – fundamentally, excommunication.”
Leo has not commented publicly since the ordinations were carried out.
The Society
The society, known as the SSPX, was founded in 1970 in Switzerland by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, a French prelate, but five years later was officially suppressed by the Bishop of Fribourg. In 1988, the group ordained four bishops without papal approval, which led to their excommunication.
The latest action from the Vatican goes further than the sanctions in 1988, which were limited to the bishops. While Pope Francis had allowed the society to administer the sacraments of marriage and confession, the latest Vatican ruling states that any marriage or confession offered by the group will be considered “invalid.”
The note does say, however, that “the Church, as a caring mother, will welcome with sincere affection and active care all those who wish to return to full communion.”
The Split
At the heart of the splintering from the mainstream church was Lefebvre and his followers’ opposition to church reforms introduced in the 1960s by the Second Vatican Council. The “Lefebvrists” do not accept what the council taught on religious freedom, ecumenism, and reforms to Catholic worship, such as celebrating Mass in languages other than Latin. One of the major reforms at the council was a condemnation of all forms of antisemitism.
During his pontificate, Leo XIV made church unity a priority, with a foundation stone of that unity being the link between the pope and the bishop. On June 16, the pope pointed out to journalists that the Lefebvrists “refuse to accept certain fundamental elements of the Church, beginning with several points of the Second Vatican Council.” On the planned ordinations, he said: “If that is the choice they make, I am sorry, but we must move forward.”
The US Connection
The group has an active presence in the United States, with a headquarters in Missouri and a seminary for training priests in Dillwyn, Virginia. Goldade, one of the newly ordained bishops, leads that seminary.
“The ‘modernist church’ is a desert that kills everything that it touches,” Goldade said at a service after the ordinations.
The Bottom Line
The Vatican has excommunicated the breakaway Society of Saint Pius X and its members after the ultra-traditionalist group ordained four bishops in defiance of Pope Leo XIV. The ordination ceremony included Father Michael Goldade, who leads the group’s seminary in Dillwyn, Virginia. The Vatican’s decree states that priests and lay members who formally adhere to the group are also in schism and excommunicated. The group opposes reforms introduced by the Second Vatican Council in the 1960s.
