Mayor Zohran Mamdani unveiled his long-awaited plan to close Rikers Island on Friday, but the proposal comes with a catch: he is asking the City Council to push back the legally mandated closure deadline by five years, from August 2027 to 2032.
Mamdani, who appeared on crutches after injuring himself playing soccer with the press corps the night before, said the delay was made necessary by the previous administration’s failures. “A new timeline made necessary by the prior administration’s delays,” he said .
The plan calls for four smaller borough-based jails, with the first opening in Brooklyn in 2029, followed by the Bronx and Queens in 2031, and Manhattan in 2032. The replacement jails have already cost an estimated $16 billion.
The Problem
The math is brutal. As of July, more than 6,500 people were held on Rikers. The four new jails have only 4,160 beds combined. To close Rikers, the city has to cut its jail population by more than 2,000 people.

Mamdani’s plan includes a $146 million investment in therapeutic beds, mental health care, education, and job training, with hundreds of new hospital beds to move people with serious mental illness out of jail and into care. The plan also aims to speed up evidence sharing and clear court backlogs, so people who cannot make bail are not left waiting in cells for months.
The Context
Rikers Island has been a symbol of the city’s failures for decades. The case of Kalief Browder, who spent three years on Rikers awaiting trial for stealing a backpack, much of it in solitary confinement, before his charges were dropped and he died by suicide, became the face of the movement to close the jail.
In 2019, the City Council passed a law requiring Rikers to close by August 2027. That deadline, Mamdani has acknowledged, was “practically impossible to meet” . His new plan formally abandons it.
The jail is currently under federal oversight after a judge found persistent constitutional violations. A federal remediation manager released a report just one day before Mamdani’s announcement, describing “fires set by inmates, unattended housing units, and frequent violence,” concluding that “violence remains pervasive, basic correctional practices remain unreliable, and unconstitutional conditions persist”.
The Bottom Line
Mayor Mamdani has unveiled a plan to close Rikers Island by 2032, asking the City Council to delay the legal deadline by five years. The plan requires cutting the jail population by more than 2,000 people and investing $146 million in mental health and therapeutic beds. The replacement jails have already cost $16 billion. The 2019 law requiring closure by 2027 has been effectively abandoned.
My Opinion
Zohran Mamdani ran for mayor promising to close Rikers Island. But on Friday, he announced that he is pushing the deadline back five years — a concession on his part. It is an admission that the thing he promised to do, the thing he campaigned on, the thing that became a symbol of his entire approach to criminal justice, cannot be done on the timeline the law requires.
Maybe it is not his fault. The previous administration delayed the borough-based jails. The costs have ballooned to $16 billion. The jail population is still over 6,500, and the new facilities only have room for 4,160. The math does not work. It never worked. And Mamdani, to his credit, is being honest about that.
But honesty is not the same as leadership. Leadership would have meant going to the City Council with a plan that actually met the deadline and finding a way to reduce the jail population faster; or even building the new jails quicker and fighting for the resources to make it happen.
Instead, Mamdani is asking for more time. He is asking the people who have been waiting for Rikers to close, and the families who have lost loved ones, to wait five more years.
The federal report released the day before his announcement said that violence remains pervasive and unconstitutional conditions persist. Every day that Rikers stays open is another day that people are held in a facility that a federal judge has said violates the Constitution.
Rikers Island will not close in 2027. It may not close in 2032. The people who are held there will continue to wait. And the mayor who promised to set them free is now the one asking them to wait a little longer.





