A federal judge in the United States has overturned restrictions introduced by the Donald Trump administration that would have limited the stay of foreign students in the country to four years.
US District Court for the District of Massachusetts Judge F. Dennis Saylor ruled on Monday that the Department of Homeland Security’s regulation exceeded its statutory authority and failed to consider less restrictive alternatives available to the government.
The DHS rule sought to replace the long-standing “duration of status” policy, which allows international students to remain in the US for as long as they continue making academic progress towards completing their studies.
Under the proposed changes, holders of F-1 student visas and J-1 exchange visitors would have been required to apply to the agency for extensions if they needed to stay beyond four years.
In his ruling, Saylor faulted the department for failing to demonstrate how the proposed extension process would effectively address immigration fraud.
The judge questioned the need for an entirely discretionary renewal system for students who had already spent four years in the country, particularly given the financial and administrative implications of abandoning the existing arrangement.

He wrote that the agency had not explained how the system would improve its ability to detect fraudulent cases or justify the significant costs associated with the change.
A coalition of higher education institutions and labour organisations, including the United Auto Workers, challenged the regulation, arguing that it would unnecessarily interrupt students’ academic programmes.
Saylor had earlier issued an order preventing the restrictions from taking effect in September, ruling that the DHS had failed to establish a reasonable link between the proposed measures and their stated objectives.
Reacting to the latest decision, Miriam Feldblum, president and chief executive officer of the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, described the ruling as a major win for international students and American institutions that admit them.
The organisation was among the groups that filed the lawsuit against the regulation.
Feldblum said the Trump administration’s efforts to weaken the F-1 student visa programme were already reflected in declining international student enrolment.
She added that implementing the rule would have made it more difficult for the US to attract international talent, disrupted students’ educational plans and placed additional pressure on university campuses.
“To be sure, if implemented, this rule would have further weakened our ability to attract international talent, disrupted educational plans, and burdened campuses,” she said.
The plaintiffs are being represented by McDermott Will & Schulte LLP, while the Department of Justice is representing the Department of Homeland Security.





