A Meta shareholder has sued CEO Mark Zuckerberg and 25 other executives and board members, claiming the company’s public assurances about child safety were deliberately misleading and caused Meta to overpay billions for its own stock.
Matt Eisner filed the 656-page shareholder derivative suit in Northern California federal court on Tuesday. The lawsuit names Meta Platforms as a nominal defendant and claims the defendants created a public narrative “designed to mask a systemic crisis in user engagement and growth”.
The Allegations
The lawsuit claims that to protect Meta’s revenue stream, the defendants made false assurances about child and teen safety and claimed the algorithm was fostering “meaningful interaction” when in reality “it was engineered to reward toxicity for engagement”.
It specifically calls Meta’s 2024 annual proxy filing “materially false and misleading” because it misrepresented and omitted information about how Meta protects kids on its platforms and the risks it faces from failing to do so.

The suit also names Instagram head Adam Mosseri, claiming he prioritized “‘clicks’ over child welfare” by deciding to make hiding like counts optional despite research finding that hiding them reduced harmful comparisons.
The Financial Stakes
Eisner alleges the misleading statements caused economic loss and harm to Meta. He cites the company’s $17 billion settlement in August, in addition to $25.63 billion in repurchased and retired shares for the nine months ended September 30, 2021, which he claims Meta overpaid for because the misleading statements drove up the stock price.
The lawsuit also points to $26.26 billion in buybacks in 2025, alleging the defendants’ false statements caused Meta to overpay by that amount.
Eisner is seeking corrective statements from the defendants and asks the court to block Meta from holding a shareholder meeting until those disclosures are presented to investors.
The History
This is not Eisner’s first attempt. He previously sued Meta and Zuckerberg in 2024, claiming they misled shareholders in a proxy statement about child safety. US District Judge Charles Breyer dismissed that case, saying the filing didn’t adequately demonstrate that shareholders suffered economic losses as a result of the alleged disclosure failures. Eisner is trying again with a more detailed complaint.
The Bottom Line
A Meta shareholder has sued Mark Zuckerberg and 25 other executives and board members, claiming the company misled investors about child safety to protect revenue and inflate the stock price. The lawsuit alleges Meta overpaid by $26 billion for share buybacks in 2025. It also names Instagram head Adam Mosseri for prioritizing engagement over child welfare. Meta has not publicly responded to the lawsuit.
My Opinion
Mark Zuckerberg has spent years telling the world he cares about your kids. He has testified before Congress. He has published blog posts. He has promised new tools, new controls, new protections. He has looked into the camera and said, with that strange, unblinking stare, that Meta is doing everything it can to keep children safe on its platforms.
But according to one of his own shareholders, it was all a lie. The lawsuit doesn’t just say Meta was negligent. It said that the entire public narrative about child safety was engineered to mask a crisis. It further revealed that the algorithm was designed to reward toxicity— a fact the executives knew, and they lied anyway, because the stock price depended on it.
And here is the part that should make you furious. The lawsuit claims Meta overpaid by $26 billion for its own shares because the stock was artificially inflated by those lies. That means the company spent $26 billion of its own money — shareholder money, employee pension money, your 401(k) money — buying back stock at a price that was too high because the people running the company couldn’t stop lying about how dangerous their product was for children.
Adam Mosseri is named in the suit for a decision that sounds almost comically cynical. Research showed that hiding like counts reduced harmful social comparison among teenagers. But Mosseri allegedly made hiding them optional because keeping them visible would drive engagement.
Maybe Eisner’s lawsuit will fail. His first one did. Maybe the judge will rule that the connection between the alleged lies and the financial losses is too tenuous. Maybe Meta will settle, pay a fine, and move on. That is how these things usually go.
But the allegations are out there now in a 656-page court filing, with names and numbers and internal decisions. And they tell a story that Zuckerberg has spent years trying to bury: that when it comes to Meta, child safety was never the priority. Engagement and stock price was.




