The nation’s highest court has delivered a major constitutional check on the White House’s campaign against campus diversity programs, as Trump loses Supreme Court fight over DEI grants aimed at University of California researchers. In a brief, unsigned order issued Monday in Trump v. Thakur, the justices declined to hear the administration’s appeal, leaving intact lower court rulings that found abruptly terminating federal academic grants over perceived ideological viewpoints violates the First Amendment.
The dispute stems from executive orders President Donald Trump signed upon returning to office in January 2025, directing federal agencies to strip funding from initiatives linked to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), climate change, and transgender rights. While the federal government initially moved to cancel $324 million in awards across the University of California system as part of a broader nationwide funding purge, roughly $59 million in remaining grant funds from the National Science Foundation (NSF) and the National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH) was directly at stake in Monday’s appeal.

Discrimination, and Lower Court Rulings
Researchers across the University of California system sued after federal agencies canceled active grants en masse, arguing that officials relied on automated keyword scans targeting disfavored terms such as “diversity” and “climate change”. According to court filings, that blunt screening method swept up purely scientific projects, including studies titled “Leaf Diversity” and “Diversity Within the Legume Rhizobia Mutualism” simply because of the words in their titles.
U.S. District Judge Rita Lin ordered the administration to restore the terminated NSF and NEH awards after concluding the cuts likely amounted to unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination. In May, the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that injunction, ruling that the government had not merely chosen which new programs to create, but instead canceled existing grants based on the perceived viewpoints of individual researchers. Solicitor General D. John Sauer urged the Supreme Court to step in, arguing that forcing taxpayers to fund projects that clash with a president’s policy priorities undermines democratic accountability.
However, the justices turned away the appeal without noted dissent, even as a separate procedural ruling by the 9th Circuit still requires researchers to pursue any past unpaid funds through the U.S. Court of Federal Claims.
Implications for Academic Freedom and Federal Research
By refusing to disturb the appellate injunction, the Supreme Court ensured that the remaining NSF and NEH research projects, some scheduled to run through November 2029, can keep operating across California campuses while litigation continues. While the high court could still review separate disputes governing how future federal grants are structured, Monday’s order sends a clear signal that the executive branch cannot use crude political litmus tests to retroactively yank approved science and humanities funding.
Ultimately, as Trump loses Supreme Court fight over DEI grants, universities and scientists nationwide gain crucial protection against ideological interference in publicly funded research.
My View
Slashing active scientific and humanities research simply because an automated computer search flagged the word “diversity” is reckless governance dressed up as fiscal discipline.
The First Amendment exists precisely to stop the government from using public money as a weapon to punish ideas or words politicians dislike. By leaving the lower court rulings intact, the Supreme Court upheld a vital boundary: elected leaders can set broad budget priorities, but they cannot turn federal science agencies into political thought police.





