Meta’s popular messaging platform, WhatsApp, has revealed that Israeli spyware company Paragon Solutions targeted scores of its users, including journalists and members of civil society. This revelation exposes the ongoing threat of sophisticated surveillance tools and raises serious concerns about privacy and freedom of expression.
WhatsApp Takes Legal Action: Cease-and-Desist Letter Issued to Paragon
Following the discovery of the hack, WhatsApp sent Paragon a cease-and-desist letter, demanding that the company immediately stop targeting its users. In a statement, WhatsApp reaffirmed its commitment to protecting users’ ability to communicate privately and securely.
Paragon’s Silence: No Comment on WhatsApp Spyware Allegations
Paragon Solutions has declined to comment on the allegations made by WhatsApp. This silence raises further questions about the company’s practices and its role in the broader spyware industry.
Targeted Attack: Approximately 90 WhatsApp Users Affected
According to a WhatsApp official, the company detected an attempt to hack approximately 90 user accounts on its platform. While the official declined to specify the exact identities or geographic locations of the targets, they confirmed that journalists and members of civil society were among those affected.
WhatsApp has referred the targeted users to Citizen Lab, a Canadian internet watchdog group, for further investigation and support. Citizen Lab researchers are working to analyze the attack and gather more information about Paragon’s spyware capabilities.
Law Enforcement and Industry Partners Collaborate to Combat Spyware
WhatsApp has informed law enforcement and industry partners about the Paragon spyware attack. The company is working collaboratively with these entities to address the threat and hold those responsible accountable. The FBI did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Spyware Proliferation: A Threat to Journalists, Activists, and Human Rights
The targeting of journalists and civil society members highlights the ongoing proliferation of mercenary spyware and its potential for abuse. Such tools, often sold to governments under the guise of national security, have repeatedly been used to target individuals critical of those in power.
Paragon Solutions, which was recently acquired by AE Industrial Partners, has attempted to portray itself as a responsible player in the spyware industry, claiming to sell only to stable democratic governments. However, the WhatsApp attack exposes the hypocrisy of these claims and demonstrates the inherent risks associated with the commercial spyware market.
Experts View: Spyware Abuses Are a “Feature, Not a Bug”
John Scott-Railton, a researcher at Citizen Lab, emphasized that the Paragon case is a reminder that mercenary spyware continues to spread, leading to familiar patterns of abuse. Natalia Krapiva, of Access Now, echoed these concerns, stating that such abuses are not isolated incidents but rather a systemic problem within the commercial spyware industry.
